Northside Hardware's bank account grew by $43,000 in January. Its owner would have told you the business made $43,000 that month — the same mistake that quietly sinks otherwise-healthy businesses. The real, accrual-basis profit was $7,900 — a gap of $35,100 that had nothing to do with a mistake, and everything to do with counting cash as if it were profit.
Key takeaways
- Bank balance up ≠ profit. Northside Hardware's cash-basis figure of $43,000 fell to a real profit of just $7,900 once unrecorded items were added back in.
- Four things caused the gap: unearned customer deposits, an unpaid supplier bill, vehicle depreciation, and inventory shrinkage — none of them showed up in the cash total.
- A loan instalment that looked like 27.9% of profit was actually 151.9% of the real profit — nearly impossible to sustain from trading alone.
- This is exactly the mechanism behind the profit and cash flow formulas: cash counts money moving, profit counts value earned.
- The fix isn't a smarter spreadsheet — it's recognizing these four items every month, not just when a loan payment suddenly doesn't add up.
The cash-basis version the owner believed
Northside Hardware is a building-supplies store. Here's what its January bank activity looked like, exactly as it appeared on the statement:
| Item | Amount |
|---|---|
| Cash in (sales, including project deposits) | $185,000 |
| Cash out (stock, wages, operating costs) | $142,000 |
| "Profit," cash-basis | $43,000 |
$185,000 − $142,000 = $43,000. The arithmetic is correct. The conclusion — "we made $43,000 this month" — is not, because two of the items buried inside that $185,000 of cash in were not revenue at all, and two real costs never left the bank in January even though the business had already incurred them.
What the cash total was hiding
Four corrections turn the cash number into the real, accrual-basis profit. Each one is a case covered in more depth elsewhere in this course — here, they're applied together, on one set of books, in one month.
| Correction | Amount | Why it doesn't belong in profit yet (or already should) |
|---|---|---|
| Deposits on 2 unfinished projects | −$15,000 | Cash the customer paid up front for work not yet done — a liability, not revenue, until the job is complete |
| Unpaid supplier invoice for stock already sold | −$12,500 | The cost was incurred the moment that stock sold — it doesn't wait for the bill to be paid |
| Vehicle depreciation ($180,000 ÷ 5 years ÷ 12 months) | −$3,000 | The truck was paid for in a past month; only this month's slice of its value counts as this month's expense |
| Stock damaged or missing, found at stock count | −$4,600 | A real loss of inventory value that never appeared as a cash transaction at all |
| Total correction | −$35,100 |
$43,000 − $35,100 = $7,900 — the real, accrual-basis profit for January.
That's a drop of 81.6% from what the bank balance suggested. Nothing was stolen and nothing was miscounted in the cash figures themselves; every dollar of the $35,100 was a real economic event that simply hadn't touched the bank account yet — or, in the case of the customer deposits, had touched the bank account but didn't belong to profit at all.
A business can show a profit and still run out of cash when that profit sits in unpaid invoices or inventory. Northside Hardware shows the same pattern: a $43,000 cash figure hid $27,500 of unearned deposits and unpaid bills, plus $7,600 of real costs (depreciation, shrinkage) with no cash movement at all — leaving a true profit of just $7,900.
Featured answer
Why this matters more once there's a loan involved
Northside Hardware pays $12,000 a month on a loan instalment. Measured against the number the owner believed, that looks manageable:
$12,000 ÷ $43,000 = 27.9% of "profit" — comfortable, on the surface.
Measured against the real number:
$12,000 ÷ $7,900 = 151.9% of actual profit — the instalment alone is half again bigger than the entire month's earnings. This business cannot pay that loan from trading profit; it's paying it out of cash reserves, this month's customer deposits, or by delaying its own supplier payments — none of which can continue indefinitely.
This is the trap: a loan repayment doesn't reduce profit at all (it reduces a liability, not an expense), so it never shows up as a warning sign in the profit figure. It only shows up as a hole in the cash figure — and by the time that hole is visible, the money is already gone. See the profit and cash flow formulas for exactly why loan principal sits outside both formulas' obvious view.
The journal entries behind the two biggest corrections
Recording these two items properly is what would have shown the real number before month-end, not after:
| Account | Debit | Credit |
|---|---|---|
| Cash | 15,000 | |
| Customer deposits (liability) | 15,000 |
| Account | Debit | Credit |
|---|---|---|
| Cost of goods sold | 12,500 | |
| Accounts payable | 12,500 |
Neither entry touches cash a second time — the cash side of the deposit was already recorded when it arrived. What changes is where the $15,000 sits (a liability, not revenue) and whether the $12,500 cost is recognized now, when the stock actually sold, instead of waiting for the supplier to be paid.
Vehicle depreciation and inventory shrinkage are easy to skip because neither one involves writing a check. Skipping them doesn't make the cost disappear — it just means the same $7,600 shows up as one large, unexplained hit whenever someone finally does a stock count or reviews the asset register. Recording $3,000 of depreciation and $4,600 of shrinkage in January is far less disruptive than discovering $7,600 of it in June.
Northside Hardware, as a sole proprietorship, still qualifies for Indonesia's 0.5% Final Income Tax (PPh Final UMKM) scheme as of 2026 — and that tax is calculated on turnover, not on profit. Its January tax bill doesn't shrink along with the correction made to its accrual profit, because the tax was never based on the accrual figure in the first place. Under this regime (established by Law No. 7/2021 / UU HPP and made a permanent rate by PP 20/2026), the first Rp500,000,000 (Rp500 million) of a sole trader's turnover in a tax year is exempt from this Final Tax — a real Rupiah figure, not a converted or scaled one. Rules and thresholds like this vary by country and change over time — check your local requirements.
Reading the same trap in your own numbers
The corrections won't be identical for every business, but the categories almost always are — the same four categories reappear whether a business runs cash or accrual basis day to day. Before trusting a monthly bank-balance increase, check for:
- Customer deposits or down payments received for work not yet finished.
- Supplier bills for goods or services already used, but not yet paid.
- Depreciation on any vehicle, equipment, or fixture bought with cash in a previous month.
- Inventory loss — damage, theft, or shrinkage — not yet counted since the last stock check.
Quick self-test
If your bank balance rose by $10,000 this month, and you have $2,000 of customer deposits for undelivered work, $1,500 of unpaid supplier bills for stock already sold, and $500 of monthly depreciation, what's your real accrual profit?
Answer: $10,000 − $2,000 − $1,500 − $500 = $6,000. The bank balance overstated profit by $4,000 — exactly the size of the unrecorded items.
Reyuko's transaction chain is built so these corrections happen automatically instead of being discovered at month-end. A customer down payment taken before the job is finished posts to a deferred revenue liability account, not straight to sales revenue, until the related Invoice is issued. A Purchase Bill posts inventory and clears the Goods Received Not Invoiced account to Accounts Payable the moment it's recorded — it doesn't wait for the bill to actually be paid through Cash & Bank. Fixed asset depreciation runs on a schedule in Accounting → Depreciation, and Inventory Checking turns a stock count directly into an adjustment entry the moment shrinkage is found. The Income Statement report reflects all of this the same day it's recorded — not weeks later.
Reyuko