Module 06 · Everyday Bookkeeping Examples

Worked Example: Reconciling the Cash Drawer from Open to Close

A cash over and short journal entry debits Cash Over and Short for a shortage and credits it for an overage. A $500 float example shows the math.

6 min readLesson 10 of 13 in this moduleUpdated 2026-08-25

Knowing how to reconcile a cash drawer at the end of the day comes down to one comparison: what the register expects to be sitting in the till, against what's physically counted. Get a mismatch, and the difference has to be recorded — not quietly folded into the next day's opening float. Below is the full worked example, using the same Tuesday at Dusk Coffee from the full day of journal entries that came before it. The monthly counterpart, matching the bank statement to your books, is covered in how to do a bank reconciliation.

Key takeaways

  • Reconciling a drawer means comparing an expected cash balance (opening float + cash sales − cash paid out) against the physical count.
  • Card, QR and bank-deposit transactions never touch the physical drawer — only cash in and cash out affect this reconciliation.
  • A shortfall is recorded by debiting Cash Over and Short and crediting Cash; an overage is the reverse.
  • Petty cash is reconciled separately, on its own schedule against its own receipts — mixing it into the daily drawer count makes both harder to trace.
  • A pattern of one-directional variance — always short, rarely over — is worth investigating on its own, not just adjusting away.

Starting from the same day's entries

Reconciling the drawer isn't a separate bookkeeping system — it's a check on the cash-only transactions already recorded that day. Of the eight entries in Dusk Coffee's Tuesday, only four ever touched the physical till: the cash sales, the cash purchase of ingredients, the petty cash top-up, and the owner's cash withdrawal. Add the $500 float the till already held at opening — carried over from the previous close, not a new entry of its own — and that's the full cash picture for the day. Card sales, the customer deposit, and the bank transfer all moved money through the bank account instead, so they sit outside this count entirely.

Reconciling a drawer means comparing expected cash (opening float plus register cash sales minus cash paid out) to the physical count at close. A shortfall debits Cash Over and Short and credits Cash; an overage debits Cash and credits Cash Over and Short — both bring the drawer to the counted amount before the next day opens. To see how matching a statement to your books works in general, read automated bank reconciliation software explained.

Building the expected balance

Dusk Coffee opens the till each morning with a fixed $500 float — enough to make change without needing a bank run before the first sale. From there, every cash movement during the day either adds to or subtracts from that starting point.

Time Description Cash in Cash out
Morning Opening float $500.00 —
Midday Cash sales (coffee and food) $2,150.00 —
Midday Ingredients bought for cash at the market — $350.00
Afternoon Petty cash tin topped up — $150.00
Afternoon Owner's drawings — $200.00
Close Cash deposited to the bank — $1,500.00
Close Totals $2,650.00 $2,200.00

Expected closing cash = $2,650.00 − $2,200.00 = $450.00. Quick check: $500 + $2,150 − $350 − $150 − $200 − $1,500 = $450 — the same figure, arrived at by adding the movements directly instead of totaling the two columns first.

Counting the physical drawer

At close, the till is counted, note by note and coin by coin, with nobody looking at the till tape while doing it — counting against a number you already expect to see is how genuine errors get missed. Two outcomes are possible: the count matches $450.00 exactly, or it doesn't.

If it matches: nothing to record

If the physical count is exactly $450.00, the day is done. No entry is needed for the drawer itself — the reconciliation is the confirmation that Tuesday's cash entries were recorded correctly, not a transaction of its own.

If it doesn't: record cash over or short

Suppose the actual count comes to $446.00 — $4.00 short of the $450.00 expected. Rather than leaving the discrepancy unrecorded or quietly adjusting the opening float for Wednesday, it's posted to a dedicated account:

Tuesday close — till counted $4.00 short of the $450.00 expected
Account Debit Credit
Cash over and short 4.00
Cash 4.00

If the drawer had instead held $454.00 — $4.00 more than expected — the entry runs the other way:

Alternative — till counted $4.00 over the $450.00 expected
Account Debit Credit
Cash 4.00
Cash over and short 4.00

Either way, the drawer is adjusted to match the physical count, and the variance is visible in its own account rather than hidden inside Sales or an expense line.

Don't bury a shortage in an existing expense account

Recording a $4 shortfall as "miscellaneous supplies" or absorbing it silently into the next day's float makes it invisible in your reports. A dedicated Cash Over and Short account lets you see, over weeks and months, whether small variances are random noise or a pattern worth a closer look — a wrong-change habit, a till left unattended, or something worse.

What usually causes a variance

A short till is far more common than an over one, and almost always traces back to something mundane:

Likely cause How it shows up
Incorrect change given Consistently small shortages across a shift
An unrecorded discount or voided sale The register total doesn't match what was actually charged
A missed cash entry A transaction happened but was never rung up or logged
Simple miscounting at close A one-off variance that doesn't recur the next day
Theft Persistent, larger, or always-in-one-direction shortages

There's no universal legal threshold for how much variance is "acceptable" — most small businesses set their own internal tolerance, often no more than a dollar or two per shift, and look into anything beyond it. What matters more than any single day's number is the pattern: an occasional dollar either way is normal human error; a shortage every single shift, never an overage, is worth a direct conversation before it's written off as bad luck. Burying a recurring shortfall in an unrelated expense account instead of tracking it is one of the everyday recording mistakes worth ruling out first.

Petty cash is a separate count

It's tempting to fold the petty cash tin into the same daily count, since both are physical cash sitting somewhere on the premises. Don't. Petty cash runs on the imprest system — a fixed float, replenished periodically against its own receipts, defined in full in the glossary of everyday transaction terms — and reconciling it on a different schedule against a different set of documents. Mixing the two counts means that if either is off, you can no longer tell which fund the discrepancy actually came from.

What you need before you start

Four things have to be on hand before a drawer can be reconciled at all: the register's end-of-day report, the opening float amount, a record of any cash paid out during the day, and the physical count itself. Missing any one of them turns "here's a $4 variance" into "the till doesn't match, for reasons we can't isolate" — a much harder problem to actually solve, and one worth avoiding by recording every cash movement as it happens rather than trying to reconstruct the day from memory at close.

Doing this in Reyuko

Reyuko's Cash & Bank module keeps a running balance for every cash account as transactions post through Sales, Purchase and payments — so the "expected" side of a reconciliation is already calculated before anyone counts a single note. A shortage or overage between that expected figure and a physical count is recorded as its own journal entry through General Journal, keeping it visible rather than folded into another account.

Cash & Bank and the General Journal are both part of Reyuko's free edition — daily reconciliation doesn't require a paid plan.

Reconcile your own drawer today

Try it: a drawer with a $12 discrepancy

Opening float $300. Cash sales per the register: $1,480. Cash paid out for a supplier delivery: $95. Physical count at close: $1,673.

Expected balance: $300 + $1,480 − $95 = $1,685. Physical count: $1,673. That's $12 short of expected.

Cash over and short   12
  Cash                     12

Frequently asked questions

What journal entry does a short cash drawer need?

Debit Cash Over and Short and credit Cash for the missing amount. For example, if a drawer should hold $450 but the count is $446, debit Cash Over and Short 4 and credit Cash 4. This brings the drawer to the physical count, and the variance stays in its own account rather than hiding inside Sales or an expense.

What journal entry does a cash drawer with extra money need?

Debit Cash and credit Cash Over and Short for the extra amount, which is the reverse of a shortage. If the expected $450 is actually $454, debit Cash 4 and credit Cash Over and Short 4. The drawer then matches the count before the next day opens with its float.

Is cash over and short an expense or revenue?

It is a minor account that can work as either. A shortage is a debit to it, so it acts like a small expense, while an overage is a credit, so it acts like small income. Its net balance over a period decides how it appears in the reports, and keeping it separate keeps the variance visible.

What is the expected cash balance of a drawer at close?

Expected cash is the opening float plus cash sales minus cash paid out, including cash taken to the bank. For example, a $500 float plus $2,150 of cash sales, minus $350 of ingredients, $150 petty cash top-up, $200 owner drawings and $1,500 deposited, gives $450. Card and bank transfers never touch the drawer, so leave them out.

What usually causes a cash variance?

Most variances come from incorrect change given, an unrecorded discount or voided sale, a missed cash entry, or a simple miscount at close. A drawer that is short every shift and never over is a pattern to investigate, since it can point to a habit or to theft, rather than being written off as chance.

What if the drawer is off by a few cents every day?

Do not round it away or fold it into the next day float. Record each day difference in Cash Over and Short and review that account over several weeks. Occasional cents either way are normal miscounting, but the same shortage every day is a pattern worth tracing to till routines such as giving change.

Close the drawer without doing the math

Reyuko's Cash & Bank module keeps a running expected balance for every cash account, so counting the till is a check against a number the system already has.

Download Reyuko freeSee what's included