Module 07 · Inventory Accounting and COGS in Practice

FIFO vs Average Cost for a Growing Retailer: When Does It Matter?

Does FIFO save a growing retailer money compared with average cost? A worked example shows the effect on COGS, profit, inventory value and tax timing.

11 min readLesson 6 of 10 in this moduleUpdated 2026-11-09

FIFO does not save a growing retailer money; it changes when cost reaches your income statement. When purchase prices rise, FIFO charges the older, cheaper layers to cost of goods sold first, so reported profit is higher and ending inventory is worth more than under average cost. In the example below, 600 units sold produce a COGS of $6,550.00 under FIFO and $6,676.67 under average cost, a $126.67 gap that reverses later. Total cost over the life of the stock is identical.

Key takeaways

  • The costing method decides how purchase cost is split between this period's COGS and the inventory you carry forward. It never changes what you paid suppliers or the cash you hold.
  • With rising prices, FIFO reports lower COGS, higher gross profit and higher inventory than average cost. With falling prices, the pattern flips.
  • The gap depends on how far prices move and how fast stock turns. With flat prices there is no gap at all; with the larger price steps in our example the gap doubles.
  • A higher reported profit usually means tax is due sooner, so FIFO is not a tax saving. Rules differ by country, so check local requirements.
  • Choose the method that fits your stock (expiry dates, price swings, effort) and apply it consistently. LIFO is not permitted under IFRS (IAS 2), though it is allowed in the United States.

What changes when you switch between FIFO and average cost?

Both methods answer the same question: when you sell a unit, which purchase price do you charge to cost of goods sold? FIFO (first in, first out) uses the oldest purchase layer still in stock. Average cost blends the layers into one running unit cost. If you want the mechanics first, read FIFO vs average costing explained; this lesson asks a different question: does the choice matter enough to change your decision?

The answer comes from one identity. Everything you buy ends up either in COGS or in ending inventory:

Opening inventory + Purchases = COGS + Ending inventory

Switching methods moves cost between the two sides of the equals sign. It cannot change the left side.

Because the left side is fixed, a method that reports a lower COGS this month must report a higher ending inventory, and the difference comes back as higher COGS in a later month once that stock sells. That is why "FIFO saves money" is a misreading. It moves profit between periods.

Worked example: three purchase layers at rising prices

Lakeside Home Goods stocks a ceramic planter. Prices from its supplier are climbing, so each purchase layer costs more than the one before. It sells every unit at $20. The numbers in this example are fictional, chosen to make the arithmetic easy to follow.

DateEventUnitsUnit costLayer cost
Mar 1Opening stock200$10.00$2,000.00
Mar 8Purchase300$11.00$3,300.00
Mar 12Sale350
Mar 20Purchase300$12.50$3,750.00
Mar 25Sale250

Goods available for sale: 800 units costing $2,000.00 + $3,300.00 + $3,750.00 = $9,050.00. Units sold: 600, so revenue is 600 × $20 = $12,000.00. Units left: 200. The business keeps a perpetual record, so cost is calculated at the moment of each sale.

How FIFO costs each sale

On Mar 12, 350 units leave. FIFO takes the 200 opening units at $10.00 and then 150 of the Mar 8 units at $11.00: $2,000.00 + $1,650.00 = $3,650.00. That leaves 150 units at $11.00 ($1,650.00). After the Mar 20 purchase, the Mar 25 sale of 250 units takes the remaining 150 at $11.00 and 100 of the new units at $12.50: $1,650.00 + $1,250.00 = $2,900.00. The 200 units still on the shelf are all from the Mar 20 layer: 200 × $12.50 = $2,500.00.

How average cost values each sale

Average cost recalculates a running unit cost after every purchase. After the Mar 8 purchase, 500 units cost $5,300.00, an average of $10.60. The Mar 12 sale of 350 units is charged at $10.60: $3,710.00, leaving 150 units worth $1,590.00. The Mar 20 purchase adds 300 units for $3,750.00, so 450 units now cost $5,340.00, an average of $11.8667 per unit (shown as $11.87 on screen). The Mar 25 sale of 250 units costs 250 × $11.8667 = $2,966.67. The remaining 200 units are worth $2,373.33.

Side-by-side results

MeasureFIFOAverage costDifference
Revenue (600 × $20)$12,000.00$12,000.00$0.00
COGS, Mar 12 sale$3,650.00$3,710.00-$60.00
COGS, Mar 25 sale$2,900.00$2,966.67-$66.67
Total COGS$6,550.00$6,676.67-$126.67
Gross profit$5,450.00$5,323.33+$126.67
Gross margin45.4%44.4%+1.0 pt
Ending inventory (200 units)$2,500.00$2,373.33+$126.67
COGS + ending inventory$9,050.00$9,050.00$0.00

The last row is the check that matters. Both methods account for the same $9,050.00 of cost. FIFO simply leaves $126.67 more of it on the balance sheet. To see the same arithmetic as a journal, read cost of goods sold explained and inventory accounting journal entries.

Does FIFO save a growing retailer money on tax?

No, and in a rising-price market it usually does the opposite in the short run. Taxable profit generally starts from accounting profit, so higher reported profit under FIFO means a larger tax bill for the same period. Suppose, purely as an illustrative assumption, a flat 25% tax on profit:

ItemFIFOAverage cost
Gross profit (ignoring other expenses)$5,450.00$5,323.33
Tax at an assumed 25%$1,362.50$1,330.83
Difference+$31.67

The extra $31.67 is not lost. The $126.67 of cost sitting in FIFO's inventory becomes COGS when those 200 units sell, and the tax on it falls in that later period. To prove it, assume the remaining 200 units sell in April at $20 each ($4,000.00 revenue) with no further purchases:

PeriodFIFO gross profitAverage cost gross profit
March$5,450.00$5,323.33
April (COGS $2,500.00 vs $2,373.33)$1,500.00$1,626.67
Two months combined$6,950.00$6,950.00

Over the two months the totals match to the cent. What differs is the timing, which matters for cash if you pay tax on a schedule, and for how the first month looks to a lender or to you.

Tax rules vary by country

Some jurisdictions require or forbid particular inventory methods for tax, or require the tax method to match your accounting method. Treat the 25% above as an illustration and check your local rules or a qualified adviser before choosing.

When does the choice actually matter?

In the example above, a 10% to 14% step between layers produced a $126.67 gap on $12,000.00 of sales, about one percentage point of gross margin. Three factors make the gap larger or smaller.

1. How far purchase prices move

The same quantities with larger price steps (opening $10.00, then $12.00, then $15.00) give these results:

Scenario (layer prices)FIFO COGSAverage COGSFIFO profit minus average profitFIFO ending inventory minus average
Rising: $10.00, $11.00, $12.50$6,550.00$6,676.67+$126.67+$126.67
Rising faster: $10.00, $12.00, $15.00$7,100.00$7,353.33+$253.33+$253.33
Falling: $10.00, $9.00, $8.00$5,500.00$5,406.67-$93.33-$93.33
Flat pricesSameSame$0.00$0.00

If your supplier prices are steady, the two methods give nearly identical results and you can pick on convenience alone. When they swing, the methods diverge.

2. How fast stock turns

A retailer that sells its stock within a few weeks drains the old layers quickly, so FIFO and average cost converge within one or two months. Slow-moving stock keeps old layers on the shelf for a long time, which widens the gap between what FIFO and average cost say the inventory is worth. If you are calculating how quickly you sell through stock, the cost of goods sold lesson shows where COGS sits in the margin calculation.

3. How you read your own numbers

FIFO produces an ending inventory close to current replacement cost, since the newest layers remain. That is helpful if you compare your balance sheet with what a restock would cost. It also produces a gross margin that looks richer when prices rise, because old, cheap cost is matched against today's selling price. Average cost smooths both. Neither is "more accurate"; each states a different assumption.

When FIFO is the natural fit

  • Perishable or dated goods. If stock is physically sold oldest first (food, cosmetics, anything with an expiry), FIFO matches what really happens on the shelf. Some systems also offer FEFO, first expired first out, for stock with expiry dates.
  • Batch-level traceability. If you already record each purchase as a separate batch and want COGS to follow it, FIFO needs no extra effort.
  • Falling or stable prices where you want conservative profit. When prices fall, FIFO gives lower profit than average cost, which some owners prefer.

When average cost is the simpler choice

  • Interchangeable, high-volume items (screws, packaging, bulk ingredients) where the batch of origin is irrelevant.
  • Frequent price changes where you want month-to-month margins to stay steady rather than jumping when an old layer runs out.
  • Small teams. One running unit cost per product is easy to audit by hand.

For a decision framework, see how to choose FIFO or average costing. Whichever you pick, apply it consistently from period to period. Changing methods to flatter a single month makes trends meaningless and may need disclosure or approval under local rules.

What about LIFO?

LIFO (last in, first out) charges the newest layers to COGS first. In a rising-price market it reports the lowest profit and the lowest inventory value of the three methods. IFRS (IAS 2) does not permit LIFO. The United States allows it, and where LIFO is used for tax there it generally has to be used in the financial statements too (the "LIFO conformity" idea), so it is not a free choice there either. If your business reports under IFRS or a local standard based on it, treat LIFO as unavailable for your financial statements and confirm anything else with your accountant.

Using the stock-out illustration from Reyuko's manual: with 10 units at 100 and 10 units at 120, removing 15 units costs 1,600 under FIFO (10 × 100 + 5 × 120), 1,650 under average (15 × 110) and 1,700 under LIFO (10 × 120 + 5 × 100). When prices only rise, as here, the usual ordering is FIFO lowest cost, LIFO highest and average in between.

Mistakes that make the comparison go wrong

  1. Comparing a period-end average with a perpetual average. A single average computed once a month gives a different answer from a running average recalculated after every purchase. Compare like with like.
  2. Ignoring negative stock. Selling before recording the purchase breaks both methods because there is no layer to cost the sale from.
  3. Mixing methods across products without noting it. It is fine to choose per product, but reports then blend assumptions; document the choice.
  4. Treating the profit gap as cash. The $126.67 in the example is an accounting timing difference, not money in the bank.
  5. Forgetting freight and discounts. Costs such as inbound freight belong in the unit cost of each layer, otherwise both methods are wrong in the same direction. The common mistakes in inventory and costing lesson covers more of these.
How Reyuko handles costing methods

In Reyuko you set the cost method per product: Average, FIFO, LIFO or FEFO. Each sale draws its cost from your purchase batches using that method, and the invoice posts COGS (debit) and Inventory (credit) at the same time as revenue, because Reyuko keeps a perpetual record. The same method values every stock-out, including adjustments and stock-take shortages, so your inventory value and cost of sales stay consistent.

Where to go next

To see a full month's COGS built from an income statement, continue to COGS worked example from start to finish. For losses that costing methods then have to value, see inventory shrinkage and write-downs. Margin definitions are in gross margin vs net margin.

Frequently asked questions

Does FIFO or average cost give a higher profit?

It depends on price direction. When purchase prices are rising, FIFO charges older, cheaper costs to COGS first, so it reports a higher profit than average cost. When prices are falling, FIFO reports a lower profit. When prices are flat, both methods give the same result. Over the full life of the stock, total profit is identical either way.

When does FIFO costing actually save a growing retailer money compared with average cost?

Strictly, it never saves money, because the total cost of the goods is the same under both methods. FIFO changes timing: in a rising-price market it shows higher profit and inventory value now and pushes the cost into later periods. That can improve how the business looks to lenders, but it can also bring tax forward, so it is not a saving.

Is average cost better than FIFO?

Neither is better in general. FIFO suits stock that is physically sold oldest first, such as dated goods, and gives an inventory value near current cost. Average cost suits interchangeable items and smooths margins when prices move often. Choose based on your stock and workload, then apply the method consistently from period to period.

Why is LIFO not allowed under IFRS?

IAS 2 prohibits LIFO; a common criticism of LIFO is that it can leave inventory on the balance sheet at very old costs that no longer reflect recent prices. The United States allows LIFO, so a company there may use it while a company reporting under IFRS may not. Check which standard your jurisdiction requires.

Can I switch from FIFO to average cost?

You can change methods, but a change should have a good reason, such as the old method no longer fitting your stock, and it is usually applied consistently from a clear date. Switching to improve one month's profit makes your trends unreliable. Some jurisdictions require disclosure or approval, so confirm local rules or ask your accountant before you change.

Put this into practice in Reyuko

Reyuko posts inventory, cost of goods sold and gross profit from the same ledger, so the numbers in this lesson are the numbers on your reports.

Download Reyuko freeSee what's included